The Tale of the Sands - Discussion
The Tale of the Sands
The Tale of the Sands | Andromeda | 4/30/19 6:37 AM |
RE: The Tale of the Sands | Linda ”Polly Ester” Ö | 4/30/19 8:13 AM |
Andromeda, modified 5 Years ago at 4/30/19 6:37 AM
Created 5 Years ago at 4/30/19 6:37 AM
The Tale of the Sands
Posts: 393 Join Date: 1/15/18 Recent Posts
More storytime with Andromeda...
Since the last story I posted was productive--for me, anyway, and hopefully for others!--I'm posting another one from the same collection which I positively adore and have been musing over for the past few days. As with 'When the Waters Were Changed,' I'll post my own thoughts after it's been on the boards for a bit so as not to influence anyone else with my own interpretation. One of the beautiful things about stories is that they sometimes have multiple valid interpretations.
-----
The Tale of the Sands
A stream, from its source in far off mountains, passing through every kind and description of countryside, at last reached the sands of the desert. Just as it had crossed every other barrier, the stream tried to cross this one, but found that as fast as it ran into the sand, its waters disappeared.
It was convinced, however, that its destiny was to cross this desert, and yet there was no way. Now a hidden voice, coming from the desert itself, whispered: "The Wind crosses the desert, and so can the stream."
The stream objected that it was dashing itself against the sand, and only getting absorbed: that the wind could fly, and this was why it could cross a desert.
"By hurtling in your accustomed way you cannot get across. You will either disappear or become a marsh. You must allow the wind to carry you over, to your destination."
But how could this happen? "By allowing yourself to be absorbed in the wind."
This idea was not acceptable to the stream. After all, it had never been absorbed before. It did not want to lose its individuality. And, once having lost it, how was one to know that it could ever be regained?
"The Wind," said the sand, "performs this function. It takes up water, carries it over the desert, and then lets it fall again. Falling as rain, the water again becomes a river."
"How can I know that this is true?"
"It is so, and if you do not believe it, you cannot become more than a quagmire, and even that could take many, many years; and it certainly is not the same as a stream."
"But can I not remain the same stream that I am today?"
"You cannot in either case remain so," the whisper said. "Your essential part is carried away and forms a stream again. You are called what you are even today because you do not know which part of you is the essential one."
When he heard this, certain echoes began to arise in the thoughts of the stream. Dimly, he remembered a state in which he--or some part of him, was it?--had been held in the arms of a wind. He also remembered--or did he?--that this was the real thing, not necessarily the obvious thing, to do.
And the stream raised his vapour into the welcoming arms of the wind, which gently and easily bore it upwards and along, letting it fall softly as soon as they reached the roof of the mountain, many, many miles away. And because he had had his doubts, the stream was able to remember and record more strongly in his mind the details of the experience. He reflected, "Yes, now I have learned my true identity."
The stream was learning. But the sands whispered, "We know, because we see it happen day after day; and because we, the sands, extend from the riverside all the way to the mountain."
And that is why it is said that the way in which the Stream of Life is to continue on its journey is written in the Sands.
-Idries Shah, The Tales of the Dervishes: Teaching Stories of the Sufi Masters over the Past Thousand Years
'This beautiful story is current in verbal tradition in many languages, almost always circulating among dervishes and their pupils. It was used in Sir Fairfax Cartwright's Mystic Rose from the Garden of the King, published in Britain in 1889. The present version is from Awad Afifi the Tunisian, who died in 1870.
Since the last story I posted was productive--for me, anyway, and hopefully for others!--I'm posting another one from the same collection which I positively adore and have been musing over for the past few days. As with 'When the Waters Were Changed,' I'll post my own thoughts after it's been on the boards for a bit so as not to influence anyone else with my own interpretation. One of the beautiful things about stories is that they sometimes have multiple valid interpretations.
-----
The Tale of the Sands
A stream, from its source in far off mountains, passing through every kind and description of countryside, at last reached the sands of the desert. Just as it had crossed every other barrier, the stream tried to cross this one, but found that as fast as it ran into the sand, its waters disappeared.
It was convinced, however, that its destiny was to cross this desert, and yet there was no way. Now a hidden voice, coming from the desert itself, whispered: "The Wind crosses the desert, and so can the stream."
The stream objected that it was dashing itself against the sand, and only getting absorbed: that the wind could fly, and this was why it could cross a desert.
"By hurtling in your accustomed way you cannot get across. You will either disappear or become a marsh. You must allow the wind to carry you over, to your destination."
But how could this happen? "By allowing yourself to be absorbed in the wind."
This idea was not acceptable to the stream. After all, it had never been absorbed before. It did not want to lose its individuality. And, once having lost it, how was one to know that it could ever be regained?
"The Wind," said the sand, "performs this function. It takes up water, carries it over the desert, and then lets it fall again. Falling as rain, the water again becomes a river."
"How can I know that this is true?"
"It is so, and if you do not believe it, you cannot become more than a quagmire, and even that could take many, many years; and it certainly is not the same as a stream."
"But can I not remain the same stream that I am today?"
"You cannot in either case remain so," the whisper said. "Your essential part is carried away and forms a stream again. You are called what you are even today because you do not know which part of you is the essential one."
When he heard this, certain echoes began to arise in the thoughts of the stream. Dimly, he remembered a state in which he--or some part of him, was it?--had been held in the arms of a wind. He also remembered--or did he?--that this was the real thing, not necessarily the obvious thing, to do.
And the stream raised his vapour into the welcoming arms of the wind, which gently and easily bore it upwards and along, letting it fall softly as soon as they reached the roof of the mountain, many, many miles away. And because he had had his doubts, the stream was able to remember and record more strongly in his mind the details of the experience. He reflected, "Yes, now I have learned my true identity."
The stream was learning. But the sands whispered, "We know, because we see it happen day after day; and because we, the sands, extend from the riverside all the way to the mountain."
And that is why it is said that the way in which the Stream of Life is to continue on its journey is written in the Sands.
-Idries Shah, The Tales of the Dervishes: Teaching Stories of the Sufi Masters over the Past Thousand Years
'This beautiful story is current in verbal tradition in many languages, almost always circulating among dervishes and their pupils. It was used in Sir Fairfax Cartwright's Mystic Rose from the Garden of the King, published in Britain in 1889. The present version is from Awad Afifi the Tunisian, who died in 1870.