Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/1/25 3:47 PM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Papa Che Dusko 3/1/25 4:45 PM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Bahiya Baby 3/1/25 8:47 PM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/2/25 3:25 PM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/2/25 3:19 PM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! pixelcloud * 3/2/25 4:29 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Bahiya Baby 3/2/25 4:34 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/2/25 3:32 PM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! shargrol 3/2/25 5:53 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/2/25 3:38 PM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! kettu 3/3/25 6:37 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/4/25 3:36 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Jure K 3/8/25 6:29 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/11/25 5:33 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Marino Klisovich 3/10/25 7:05 AM
RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!! Ivan Bogdan 3/11/25 5:29 AM
Ivan Bogdan, modified 23 Days ago at 3/1/25 3:47 PM
Created 23 Days ago at 3/1/25 3:47 PM

Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
Hi everyone, 
I am new to the site and in a need of advice of like minded people.
I am posting from Zagreb, Croatia, and not much in terms of Dharma is going on around here. Community is scarce and good teachers secluded themselves. There is one good Chaan (Zen) master from whom I learned basics of Zazen, but the community seems to be disipating lately.
I will start from the begining..
I stumbled upon Dharma 10 years ago when I started practicing Kempo , a martial art originating from China. The origins of the art are attributed to Bodhidharma ,the first partiarch of Chaan (Zan). Since the practice also involves sitting meditation, Zazen, mainly breath focused, with some visualizations, I also asked for some help from the local Chaan teacher. I got the basic instructions in Shamata practice and spent the next 3 years in practicing  martial art combined with the daily pratice of cca 30min of sitting meditation. Also, as an avid reader of Dharma books, I read a lot available on the internet, Theravada, Mahayana, Tibetan Varyayana, Shingon, I read it all.However,  I had zero structure in my aims and no idea of any kind of Vipassana meditation. I stumbled upon Geoenke, but the body scanning methods seemed to me as a begining of Zazen so I did not pursue it. I made some progress in concentration but I wasn't satisfied. Where is the real progress in insight? How do I get to stream entry?
Then I tried the entheogen Ayaguasca and had a powerful experience, visions, ego dissolving, all as advertised. It seemed to push me further on my path. After that I reached my heights in concentration practice, I could train Kempo and yoga for hours without getting tired, it all seemed as going in a meaningful direction. In my sitting mediation I think that I broke through into the dhyana territory, but I am not sure how far. However, after a while the effect started to diminish and my 'powers' declined.
I had a very turbulent period in my life at the time, got divorced, remarried, and in the last 3 years I got 2 beautiful sons. I have no time to practice martial arts any more, and the cushion has not seen me for more than a year. It is all just diapers and baby food right now. Zero time for myself. Even before that I had a feeling of a steep decline. I am happy to have a great family life, but what about my spritual life? When will I have my time to dedicate to pratice, when I am 65years old? Am I going to be fit to progress at that stage. And then, one month ago,  I stumble upon the MCTB ( a coincidence?) and the Path becomes clear to me. I understood that my Shamata practices probably got me to firts, second and possibly even third dhyana when I peaked. Also, my Ayahuasca experience and its afterglow perfectly fit into a classic Arising and Passing Away experience. So, bearing in mind my current mental state ( fear, misery, hopelessness) , it seems that I have dissolved into the Dark Night and I am here to stay ( since I have no time for practicing vipassana, or anything actually,  with 2 small kids, a job and a plethora of life emergencies). There are no Vipassana groups nearby, there is an option to join the Chaan community, but am I ready to adhere to their enigmatic approach? I am not sure.
In addition, am I just deluding myself? Maybe my assesment of my abilities is overrated, maybe I gained some access concentration at best, and my AP&P is probably only a psychedelic trip..My ego talking again, the fetter I should have left behind already? 
I am aware that the only way forward is to keep with the practice, warm the cushion, start noting practice, and maybe, just maybe , equanimity is within reach. But, in the depths of this despair I cannot find the strength to start.
​​​​​​​ I feel that Dharma came to my life with purpose, I  do not want to waste this opportunity in this lifetime. If I reach the stream entry a great burden would be lifted from my shoulders, a burden carried for hundreds of lifes, thousands. However, it seems so out of reach right now..
What do you guys think? Is this a cry for help from someone who is deep into the Knowledge of Suffering aka Dark Night, or I am just deluding myself and I have a bad case of post natal depression? 
​​​​​​Many thanks in advance for any advice you can provide me!
thumbnail
Papa Che Dusko, modified 23 Days ago at 3/1/25 4:45 PM
Created 23 Days ago at 3/1/25 4:45 PM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 3476 Join Date: 3/1/20 Recent Posts
Welcome to DhO Ivan! emoticon 
And thank you for sharing!

Your description reminds me a lot of my life as a meditator emoticon Also two sons but now they are 9 and 4 years old so Im out of the diaper realm emoticon Trust me at one stage they stop using diapers but shit in life will still happen! Awakened or non-awakened, the shit will flow for as long you are alive emoticon 

I do not think you are deluding yourself! 

I would second that you have come to the Dark Night or better to think of them as the Knowledges of Suffering , the Dukkha Nanas; dissolution, fear, misery, disqust and re-observation. This stage is VERY important and to be CHERISHED while its happening! Not to be skipped so to "get out of it and reach Equanimity" emoticon This will only catapult you back into the Dkhha Nanas, which also is OK. We just restart again and again until mind learns "Acceptance of all pleasant, neutral and unpleasant experience". THIS will then lead to lovely deep High Equanimity and ... then emoticon Yes!

I would suggest not to wreck yourself with this unless you have time to sit while your baby boy is sleeping. I would meditate while he was sleeping and he would sleep for at least two hours, so 45 minutes daily practice was very much available for me.

If you are working, then try to get up earlier and sit 30 minutes in the morning and 45 minutes before bed time or in the evening when kids are sleeping.

I would absolutely suggest Active Noting for the entire sit. Relaxed in the body and relaxing tensions which can arise but actively Noting 1-5 experiences pers second. Even noting one experience every 2 seconds is fine. Observe that the speed of noting will change a few times during the sit. That is normal.

Start a log here on DhO to get feedback! This will mean a lot! Keep daily updates and keep a daily relaxed, non-heroic practice of Noting as suggested by MCTB. What helped me in a similar pre-SE situation was to Note Aloud as thought by my old teacher Kenneth Folk. Here is a video of how I did it, noting body sensations, mind states, feeling tones, mind images, urges ... Best wishes! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FeajWRJcXA
thumbnail
Bahiya Baby, modified 22 Days ago at 3/1/25 8:47 PM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/1/25 8:47 PM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 1115 Join Date: 5/26/23 Recent Posts
Another way to say it is just sit and breath. Notice the experience. Especially if it's difficult. Notice the entire myriad of stuff that happens when you sit down and breath. Back pain, fretting and perseverating, fantasizing, saying this is it, thinking this is not it, I should be more concentrated, I'm doing too much concentration etc

Take a session and really just look at it. Sit, breath, relax and just look at, feel all this stuff that's going on. 

​​​​​​​You can note it, if your able you can notice it without labeling but just lean into the mess a little. Let the truth of your experience reveal itself to you. 
thumbnail
pixelcloud *, modified 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 4:29 AM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 4:18 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 87 Join Date: 10/25/24 Recent Posts
A couple of technical things:

Look into these suggestions on Organizing Your Practice ~ SHINZEN YOUNG. You can do small hits of practice throughout the day, a few moments of noting or noticing (or whatever practice) here and there, then maybe try to fit in 20 minutes here and there, maybe go for a day with more accumulated practice time once a month. And make progress that way. Verbal noting you can do whenever you remember doing that, really, all through the day. Every noted "queazy sensations in stomach" or "negative self talk" and "mental image" or "sensations of foot on ground" is noting practice. If you think that what happens to you happens for a reason, then all your life cirumstances are your monastery and your teachers, that now teach you how to practice in a customized way just made for you. Just be patient (whenever you can ;) ) and do what you can with what you have. 

As for peak skill levels, the way attention develops will make it seem like the dukkha nanas are a step back, but they are really a step forward. Attention is just developing something new there. During A&P, center of focus was bright and clear, but in the DN center of focus is out of phase and the periphery comes online. It's a more subtle thing that is coming online. So all the desperation, the negative emotions, if you try to pinpoint them, that might not work all that well in the DN phases. You'll likely notice that these sensate patterns occur in the mid body, head, etc., but they're moving, slithering, and attention seems to do that, too, for a long while there.  So try to let the negative stuff do its twisty, queazy, icky things, but don't try to stop whatever arises, don't try to make stuff go away, or manipulate in any other way. Try to sit back, so to speak, let attention do it's thing, let attention take whatever shape it wants to do take. Let it ALL do it's twisted, chaotic seeming conga performance. When you accept the negative DN stuff, it'll come and go and ultimately resolve. If you try to grab, push, etc  it'll just twist out of your hand and be more of a problem. Things will likely be more "focused" on the periphery sometimes, but don't force that, either. Try to be receptive, try to notice sensations as they appear, try to notice that your ideals of practice are also sensations that appear and remember that this is just a part of the journey, this is just the "journey through the underworld" part of the journey. All the negative emotion/bodys sensation stuff arises on its own, is not you, doesn't satisfy. All your ideals about practice, EVERYTHING in your experience arises on its own, is not a "you" and doesn't satisfy in a way that grasping onto it would ever work. And the DN is part of the learning curve of making your peace with that. You'll go through that a bunch of times at ever deeper levels.

A simile that I quite like is that this part of the journey is like sitting in the forest at twilight and noticing all the chirps and things in the undergrowth. Again, don't try to force the center of attention to be clear. That is not what these stages are about.

All of your experience is just seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, feeling and thinking. And all the sensations at those six sense doors are impermanent - they are gone as soon as they arise, they aren't you or property of a you, and they don't ever satisfy, so holding on to this and pushing away that really doesn't work. 

It might be that you suddeny flux out into EQ and then, at some point,  fall back into A&P, then have another DN roll through. This is not because "you suck", this is merely because there is still something to learn, and your bodymind system needs to learn those lessons, needs to take that class again. This happens to a lot of practitioners. Think of all the sucky stuff as a learning opportunity. You will deal with it very differently if you view it that way. Welcome the lessons. You can fight those lessons or try as best you can to welcome them and learn them. They will roll through just the same. 

If you have jhana, use it. Concentration brings you to your cutting edge of practice, mellows you out a bit, is a temporary refuge from the troubles of the world and the practice. And it has been used as such for ages, and is recommended to be used as that until you don't need it anymore. Some can even do lateral work and jhana their way through the DN phases until they can vipassanize what they need to learn there. 

Unless your partner is also really into this meditation stuff, maybe don't try to explain overmuch. Just give her a heads up that you feel volatile and edgy, that carving out a little time here and there to sit might help, and try to do the best you can not to be a pain in the butt. 

And don't forget to enjoy your family. emoticon


Postscript:

Investigating the dark stuff can actually be quite interesting. How, exactly, do you know that you don't feel motivated to practice? That you feel icky, etc? What exactly in our experience is it that lets you know that they aren't enjoyable?  What are the moving parts of those (or any other) experiences? 
thumbnail
Bahiya Baby, modified 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 4:34 AM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 4:34 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 1115 Join Date: 5/26/23 Recent Posts
Nice answer Pixel. 

See the thing about insight is it's not about feeling good it's about noticing that you feel bad... noticing that you're suffering without trying to manipulate or modify the experience, noticing that all the tendencies towards manipulation and modification are themselves more suffering and lead to more suffering and so on. 

[Insert 4 noble truths]
shargrol, modified 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 5:53 AM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 5:52 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 2860 Join Date: 2/8/16 Recent Posts
I've worked in the past with this teacher who lives near Rijeka, Croatia:
About Hokai - Hokai

Best wishes, you're getting really good advice above!!
Ivan Bogdan, modified 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:19 PM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:19 PM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
Thank you Duško, this means a lot to me!
It's like somebody turned a light at the end of a tunnel. 
My sons are 3 and 1 years old now, and I am 47 yrs old dad. Many years of worrying ahead of me. emoticon
​​​​​​​It is important to know that other people throdded this Path and succeeded, in this day and age.
I will implement your advice!
Ivan
Ivan Bogdan, modified 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:25 PM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:25 PM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
Thanks Bahiya! I just tried and the experience is as if I am back when I only started meditatingemoticon And very much in line what you are saying.
Best,
​​​​​​​Ivan
Ivan Bogdan, modified 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:32 PM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:32 PM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
May thanks Pixel! I appreciate this a lot. You really took some time to explain and present the intricacies.
This will help me tremedously. 
All the best,
​​​​​​​Ivan
Ivan Bogdan, modified 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:38 PM
Created 22 Days ago at 3/2/25 3:38 PM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
Thank you Shagrol, actually I tried to contact him some 4 years ago and asked for mentorship.Never got any response. I understood that he is Shingon teacher, which is a rare thing to find. I might try again and see where it goes now.
Thx again,
​​​​​​​Ivan
kettu, modified 21 Days ago at 3/3/25 6:37 AM
Created 21 Days ago at 3/3/25 6:37 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 79 Join Date: 10/31/17 Recent Posts
You’ve got good advice. I’d like to underline the possibility of inner work with your family and children. While waiting for time to be alone or with like-minded adults, the kids do give you unique and intense opportunities for experiencing breaking down of the habitual ways of sensing, feeling and thinking, and might just give the little push needed to collapse from dualistic state to something else. In the worry and in the rest, in cheerful play and heart wrenching crying ... there is the possibility of ”me” and ”you” being together. Best wishes from a fellow parent without strong current spiritual framework
Ivan Bogdan, modified 20 Days ago at 3/4/25 3:36 AM
Created 20 Days ago at 3/4/25 3:36 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
Thank you Kettu, I will keep that in mind. Just this morning my first training in mindfulness with kids started emoticon

Also, the Sila part of the Noble Eithfold Path is definitely trained by having kids. I have to be mindful of my conduct, my speech and my actions all the time. My ego is tested without reserve, which is a good thing.  They came into my life as a blessing.
I wish you all the best in parenting and  in spiritual endevours, too!
thumbnail
Jure K, modified 16 Days ago at 3/8/25 6:29 AM
Created 16 Days ago at 3/8/25 6:29 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 522 Join Date: 9/8/20 Recent Posts
Welcome Ivan, dukkha nanas is another day in the office. We're lucky there's a end to it all! Ivan a word to the wise, don't get to hung up on stream entry and paths, it causes incredible amounts of suffering. To the point where I still deal with it 8 years into my practice.

Not only a fellow Croatian practitioner but apparently a Croatian dharma teacher too, thanks Shargoal! Double whammy.

PS. Duško is my fellow balkan kindred spirit on here. He always kindly reminds me i'm suffering. Guess what Duško still suffering here.
thumbnail
Marino Klisovich, modified 14 Days ago at 3/10/25 7:05 AM
Created 14 Days ago at 3/10/25 7:05 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 27 Join Date: 9/28/23 Recent Posts
Hello Ivan. You could incorporate mettā in your daily practice and work on becoming a great father and a human being. Direct your good wishes towards your family and beings in general. This practice will bring your peace, contentment and advancement on the Path. 

I have made a lot of progress on the Path with this practice of mettā. Since you're overwhelmed with daily duties, there's not much you can do regarding the Path. I reccomend you concentrate on actively sending good wishes towards your family members and create an atmosphere of love.

​​​​​​​Good luck on the path!
Ivan Bogdan, modified 13 Days ago at 3/11/25 5:29 AM
Created 13 Days ago at 3/11/25 5:29 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
Thank you Marino,
​​​​​​​you are right, not much time to do the sitting meditation right now. However, it is a good time to work on the Sila part of the 8thfold Path.

I will keep your advice in my mind during my stressy daily activities emoticon

Best,
Ivan B
Ivan Bogdan, modified 13 Days ago at 3/11/25 5:33 AM
Created 13 Days ago at 3/11/25 5:33 AM

RE: Is this the Dark Night or post natal depression, or else? Help!!

Posts: 8 Join Date: 2/28/25 Recent Posts
Thanks Jure,

dukkha, yes, absolutely, tons of it emoticon Thanks for the advice, I hope I will be able to advance on the Path and hopefully the good things will come.

Best,
Ivan B

P.S. Nice to see some balkan people here, I have a great feeling of warm welcome to this site. I am very grateful indeed!

Breadcrumb