flow chart - Discussion
flow chart
Stick Man, modified 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 8:36 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 8:36 AM
flow chart
Posts: 396 Join Date: 9/23/14 Recent Postsneko, modified 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 9:48 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 9:48 AM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 763 Join Date: 11/26/14 Recent PostsStick Man, modified 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 1:15 PM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 1:12 PM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 396 Join Date: 9/23/14 Recent Posts
As a Cockney would say - cor blimey guv!
So, I imagine you could start doing things with that - like writing instructions on the lines, and adding things like - "LSD takes you here or here", "Sex takes you here", "Jesus got to here", "Physics looks like this here, but like this here, and disappears here." ??
So, I imagine you could start doing things with that - like writing instructions on the lines, and adding things like - "LSD takes you here or here", "Sex takes you here", "Jesus got to here", "Physics looks like this here, but like this here, and disappears here." ??
Derek, modified 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 7:33 PM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 7:33 PM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 326 Join Date: 7/21/10 Recent Postssvmonk, modified 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 10:21 PM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/6/16 10:21 PM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 403 Join Date: 8/23/14 Recent Posts
Hi neko,
Cool!
Could you explain the fork between "Three Doors" and "Change of Lineage"? This seems like two ways to get to the path moment.
Thanx!
Cool!
Could you explain the fork between "Three Doors" and "Change of Lineage"? This seems like two ways to get to the path moment.
Thanx!
neko, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:16 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:16 AM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 763 Join Date: 11/26/14 Recent Posts
Hey all!
This map is not mine, it is Daniel's!
Sorry for the misunderstanding!
http://integrateddaniel.info/mind-maps-full-size/
This map is not mine, it is Daniel's!
Sorry for the misunderstanding!
http://integrateddaniel.info/mind-maps-full-size/
neko, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:17 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:17 AM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 763 Join Date: 11/26/14 Recent Postssvmonk:
Could you explain the fork between "Three Doors" and "Change of Lineage"? This seems like two ways to get to the path moment.
Again - not my map, but, according to Daniel, that is the difference between a repeat fruition and a path-grade fruition.
(I agree with him, it describes by experience adequately.)
neko, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:19 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:19 AM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 763 Join Date: 11/26/14 Recent PostsDerek:
What are you using as Nirodha Criteria?
From MCTB: Traditionally, anagamihood. Also, rising thriugh the jhanas/nanas with a balance of vipassana and samatha - basically through the midline of the graph.
neko, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:20 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:20 AM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 763 Join Date: 11/26/14 Recent PostsJohn:
As a Cockney would say - cor blimey guv!
So, I imagine you could start doing things with that - like writing instructions on the lines, and adding things like - "LSD takes you here or here", "Sex takes you here", "Jesus got to here", "Physics looks like this here, but like this here, and disappears here." ??
So, I imagine you could start doing things with that - like writing instructions on the lines, and adding things like - "LSD takes you here or here", "Sex takes you here", "Jesus got to here", "Physics looks like this here, but like this here, and disappears here." ??
Yes, that is what Daniel does in MCTB. Haven't you read it?
Noah, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:21 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:21 AM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 1467 Join Date: 7/6/13 Recent Posts
This is Daniel's chart from his site: http://integrateddaniel.info/mind-maps/
This is a recording of Daniel explaining the chart: https://vimeo.com/69475208
svmonk:
I wouldn't presume to know more about this than you, I'm moreso checking my knowledge here against other people's understandings.
My understanding is that the fruition will manifest through one of the 3 doors, regardless of whether it is a review fruition, or a path fruition. The path fruition only happens once per major shift, whereas the review fruition repeats multiple times after that, until review matures. Nanas 12, 13 & 14 are 'Conformity,' 'Change of Lineage,' and 'Path,' and only occur before the path fruition. In a review fruition, it simply jumps from Nana 11 to Nana 15 & 16.
Practically, how this pans out is that there are those weird energetic effects and micro-moments where the baseline shift/rewiring occurs in path fruition. These little trippy details are absent in the reveiw fruitions.
I think Daniel labelled that box 'Three doors' just for the sake of distinction.
Derek:
Once again, just sharing thoughts, not trying to lecture at all.
Daniel put the 'Nirodha Lite' option out there to accomodate the variety of pragmatic dharma people, including myself, who have experienced some form of it. I'm strongly convinced that the full NS is incredibly rare... like maybe 5 people in the greater pragmatic dharma community, ever. And even within that, no one can repeat it reliably outside of retreat.
This is a recording of Daniel explaining the chart: https://vimeo.com/69475208
svmonk:
Could you explain the fork between "Three Doors" and "Change of Lineage"? This seems like two ways to get to the path moment.
I wouldn't presume to know more about this than you, I'm moreso checking my knowledge here against other people's understandings.
My understanding is that the fruition will manifest through one of the 3 doors, regardless of whether it is a review fruition, or a path fruition. The path fruition only happens once per major shift, whereas the review fruition repeats multiple times after that, until review matures. Nanas 12, 13 & 14 are 'Conformity,' 'Change of Lineage,' and 'Path,' and only occur before the path fruition. In a review fruition, it simply jumps from Nana 11 to Nana 15 & 16.
Practically, how this pans out is that there are those weird energetic effects and micro-moments where the baseline shift/rewiring occurs in path fruition. These little trippy details are absent in the reveiw fruitions.
I think Daniel labelled that box 'Three doors' just for the sake of distinction.
Derek:
What are you using as Nirodha Criteria?
Once again, just sharing thoughts, not trying to lecture at all.
Daniel put the 'Nirodha Lite' option out there to accomodate the variety of pragmatic dharma people, including myself, who have experienced some form of it. I'm strongly convinced that the full NS is incredibly rare... like maybe 5 people in the greater pragmatic dharma community, ever. And even within that, no one can repeat it reliably outside of retreat.
Stick Man, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:25 AM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 5:25 AM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 396 Join Date: 9/23/14 Recent Posts
I've been nibbling at it on and off for the last few years, it's making a bit more sense to me lately.
I'm very impressed by the charts. Did the ancients ever draw anything as straightforward ?
I'm very impressed by the charts. Did the ancients ever draw anything as straightforward ?
svmonk, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 9:52 PM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 9:52 PM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 403 Join Date: 8/23/14 Recent Posts
Hi John,
I don't think a flow chart but there's a text out there, the Abhidhamma, that describes the mind states leading up to the path moment. It's the 3rd "basket" in the Pali Canon. Some of the rest I think can be found in the Visuddhimagga, the 5th century meditation manual written by Buddhaghosa, a Sri Lankan monk. I don't know whether Daniel drew on those sources or more recent ones such as Mahsi Saydaw's Manual of Insight. Clearly, though, he's gone beyond these sources and incorporated his experience over the years.
I don't think a flow chart but there's a text out there, the Abhidhamma, that describes the mind states leading up to the path moment. It's the 3rd "basket" in the Pali Canon. Some of the rest I think can be found in the Visuddhimagga, the 5th century meditation manual written by Buddhaghosa, a Sri Lankan monk. I don't know whether Daniel drew on those sources or more recent ones such as Mahsi Saydaw's Manual of Insight. Clearly, though, he's gone beyond these sources and incorporated his experience over the years.
Derek, modified 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 10:35 PM
Created 8 Years ago at 6/7/16 10:35 PM
RE: flow chart
Posts: 326 Join Date: 7/21/10 Recent Posts
Ah, okay, so it is Daniel's Nirodha Criteria, as derived from Visuddhimagga paragraphs XXIII.31 et seq.